By
Reuters
Printed
January 3, 2025
Amazon.com has fallen quick in its bid to dismiss a lawsuit that accused the e-commerce big of wounding competitors within the on-line superstore market, inflicting rival Zulily to lose gross sales and shoppers to pay greater costs.
Reuters
Seattle-based U.S. District Choose John Chun in a ruling, opens new tab on Dec. 31 mentioned Zulily can proceed with claims that a few of Amazon’s enterprise practices might violate U.S. antitrust legislation.
Zulily’s lawsuit challenged Amazon’s “anti-discounting” insurance policies that it mentioned barred retailers from providing decrease costs than these at Amazon.
The lawsuit mentioned Amazon illegally used contracts and different means to limit a whole bunch of 1000’s of third-party retailers from permitting Zulily and different websites prefer it to promote their items extra cheaply.
Chun dismissed a part of the December 2023 grievance, ruling that Zulily had not proven that third-party retailers and wholesale suppliers had been taking part in a price-fixing conspiracy. He additionally dismissed a declare that Amazon violated a Washington state shopper safety legislation.
Amazon had requested the decide to dismiss your entire lawsuit. The corporate has denied any wrongdoing.Amazon declined to touch upon Thursday. Legal professionals for Zulily didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark.
Zulily’s lawsuit mentioned its wholsesale suppliers couldn’t afford to run afoul of Amazon pricing guidelines, and that Amazon got down to destroy the corporate because it emerged as a rival on-line superstore.
Amazon countered that matching rivals’ costs was a “classic form of price competition.” Amazon additionally disputed that Zulily certified as an online superstore. It had urged Chun to rule that Zulily had no authorized standing to file a lawsuit within the first place.Days after the lawsuit was filed, Zulily closed up and entered an asset liquidation settlement. Zulily has since bought its mental property rights to its title.
Chun gave Zulily till Jan. 31 to file an amended grievance.
The case is Zulily Inc v. Amazon.com Inc, U.S. District Court docket for the Western District of Washington, No. 2:23-cv-01900-JHC.
© Thomson Reuters 2025 All rights reserved.
